Councillors clash over 'alarming' implications of private security wardens
By Stephen Holland · DublinLive · 4 November 2026

Dublin councillors are divided over a proposed pilot scheme for security to patrol the city centre alongside Gardaí, with worries stemming from a lack of transparency or debate around it's potential implications
News of private security wardens potentially patrolling Dublin city centre has come as a shock to some local councillors.
Reports of tenders being drafted to contract a security firm to provide “safety operations” and complement the work of An Garda Síochána has sparked concern. While Dublin City Council issued a statement that safety wardens will merely assist garda , rather than carry out their duties, there is still a worry about security, surveillance, or social cleansing being the most appropriate measures to tackle anti-social behaviour in the city.
“Similar to safety warden schemes in operation in other jurisdictions, appointed safety wardens would not have additional statutory powers to arrest, demand identification, require a person to leave a public street, to search persons, or issue fines/enforce local authority bye-laws,” a spokesperson for the council said.
The idea of private security patrolling the city stems from discussion between business representatives and the Dublin City Taskforce headed by Robert Watt. This is informed by the ‘10 Big Moves’ aimed at rejuvenating Dublin city centre.
Central to this plan is safety, with the council liaising with businesses, garda, and Department of Justice to develop security measures. This includes reviewing structures put in place by Irish Rail and Luas around security measures on public transport.
One councillor who sits on the Taskforce’s Interim Advisory Board is Independent Cllr Nial Ring who told Dublin Live the implementation of safety wardens on city streets is nothing new. He confirmed that Dublin Town is to act as the contracting body for the potential security service.
The plan includes the provision of over 1,000 extra garda to ensure more visible policing across the city. Dublin Town will then also fund a ‘Safety Operative’ pilot to provide extra security.
While the idea has not been discussed in detail by the Taskforce, Cllr Ring said the goal is to simply increase security presence and the sense of safety on the street. This is to complement the work of garda, with Cllr Ring stressing that just because there’s private security that doesn’t mean guards won’t be doing their normal patrols.
Green Party Cllr Janet Horner was blindsided by the news and submitted an emergency motion calling for more detail at the November monthly meeting. While the motion was not heard, DCC confirmed a full report is currently being finalised and will be brought to the December meeting.
She described private security as a "departure from any current strategy” the council has and said previously safety wardens who occasionally patrolled areas like O’Connell Street and Mountjoy Square were simply in place to provide support for people in distress. “That’s a very different proposal to what has been forward here, which is more about being the eyes and ears of the Gardaí,” she said.
Cllr Horner expressed concern about embracing an “enforcement-based approach” and highlighted the need to address addiction , homelessness, and other issues associated with anti-social behaviour. As a councillor involved with the local safety partnership and other support services, she wondered why she and other representatives had not been briefed before things got to this stage.
“It shouldn’t be bypassing proper political scrutiny. I’m concerned about the implications of having private security forces on our streets and what their accountability would be,” she said.
“It is not appropriate that the councillors are not made aware of proposals coming that are affecting their area and the city centre. It needs a lot more scrutiny than what has been kind of pushed through a subsection of the council that has not been fully transparent with the rest of the council.
“Businesses are 100% right to be concerned about some of the behaviours that do go on in Dublin city centre, nobody would dismiss their concerns, but I don't think that we can push forward a proposal that isn't interrogated.”
People Before Profit Cllr Conor Reddy has expressed concern about the Taskforce overstepping its remit. “Beyond the catching headline of a private security force in the city centre, there's a mission creep here,” he said.
He said the initial working group was focused on urban regeneration and it was his understanding that the main task of the Special Purpose Vehicle would be tackling the dereliction and vacancy part of the Dublin City Taskforce recommendations.
He expressed concern about “wading into the territory” of law enforcement and said, although there were wardens in the city centre before, their focus on advising people of public services and addressing issues like littering. “It’s not described as that now, there wasn’t private security in a public space,” he said.
Cllr Reddy described comparison made to “ICE and other pseudo-police forces” that exist around the world as “worrying.” While business leaders may be “making a play for the type of city they want to see,” he said this does truly solve core problems like poverty and social disadvantage.
“There is an issue with over-concentration of homeless services in the city centre, but again, the answer is not social cleansing. It is supports and it is longer-term planning, it's looking at how we build homes so you have homeless exits and people not living in homeless accommodation for long periods.”
Former Lord Mayor Ray McAdam sits on the board of Dublin Town and said it is his view that the proposal does not constitute private security patrolling the streets of the city. He stressed that safety wardens have been in place for several years in areas like Henry Street and Jervis Street.
“They provided reassurance to members of the public, visitors, retailers alike. They linked in closely with An Garda Síochána, and the proposal that Dublin Town are going to tender on at the moment, for me, is very much a continuation of that community warden model,” the Fine Gael rep told Dublin Live.
“They have provided a great deal of reassurance, they've dealt with support for homeless people, they've provided support and direction to Dubliners and visitors alike.”
He also expressed frustration at councillors stating they were not aware of the proposal, as the Taskforce’s Interim Advisory Board includes members from all parties who he said should be briefing their colleagues on meetings and presentations.
Cllr McAdam said he does not view the proposal as policing extending into the private sector and stressed “policing of our streets is solely a matter for An Garda Síochána, and that's the only way it should be”. “I would have no hand, act, or part in supporting any initiative that tried to replace An Garda Síochána, period,” he said.
A full report on the proposal is currently being finalised and will be on the agenda for the December monthly council meeting. DCC states the “final decision on this will respect all appropriate decision-making protocols”.
Dublin Town has confirmed their Business Improvement District group will play a role in the "implementation of a proposed pilot of a Safety Operative Scheme". They welcomed additional Garda sources and initiatives to improve safety in the city.
"Dublin Town believes security similar to that already in operation on the Luas and on Irish Rail, in addition to more Gardaí, will be a good thing for those who live, work and visit the city centre," a spokesperson said.
They added that similar schemes have been successful implemented by local authorities and police in cities throughout the UK with input from similar business groups.
"Dublin Town commissioned research by Red C into attitudes to Dublin City Centre last May. It found that while perceptions of the city centre in general are improving, safety remains a key challenge, particularly on the Northside. There was widespread reference by respondents to perceptions of safety, and says this must be addressed.
"Dublin Town will do all that it can to improve safety and perceptions of safety in the city centre, and believes this pilot will give people a sense of enhanced safety while supporting the important statutory role the Gardai play in keeping our city safe."
This content is funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme
Want to see more of the stories you love from Dublin Live? Making us your preferred source on Google means you’ll get more of our exclusives top stories and must-read content straight away. To add us as a preferred source, simply click here .
Reporting by Stephen Holland for DublinLive, funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme. Republished by News Room under the scheme’s reuse permission.
About News Room →