Look behind 'success' of private security patrolling UK cities
By Stephen Holland · DublinLive · 6 November 2026

Dublin Town has welcomed the idea of private security wardens being hired to patrol the city centre. Comparisons have been to "successful" schemes in the UK, but these initiatives are not without their own share or controversies and abuse of power accusations
Add to preferred sources Comments News Stephen Holland Local Democracy Reporter 13:29, 06 Nov 2026 Updated 16:00, 06 Nov 2026 View 2 Images Two private security personnel walk together with shoppers along Oxford Street on September 7, 2026 in London, United Kingdom (Image: John Keeble/Getty Images)
Reports of private security wardens patrolling Dublin City Centre have sparked concern, with stakeholders stating the scheme could imitate initiatives already in place in the United Kingdom.
News of a ‘Safety Operative Scheme’ came as a surprise to some Dublin councillors who felt the full implications of private security had not been properly debated before it came to public attention that tenders were being prepared.
The proposal was part of the 2024 Dublin City Taskforce Report, which was backed by Dublin Town and businesses. Many questioned what powers these safety wardens could hold, and Dublin City Council quickly issued a statement confirming they would have no additional statutory powers and would not be able to arrest people.
Instead, they would assist the work of An Garda Síochána and carry out their functions similar to security seen on public transport like the Luas .
“Similar schemes have been successfully implemented by local authorities and police in cities throughout the UK, with the input and co-operation of business groups similar to Dublin Town,” the group said. But these similar initiatives have not been without their own share of controversy, as the BBC reported security patrols in Leicestershire and Rutland were being dismissed as a “gimmick” by some.
Conservative Leicestershire county councillor for Coalville North Craig Smith branded the move an "astonishing misuse of public money". "Residents don't want security guards in fancy uniforms wandering around town centres acting as a substitute for real policing," Cllr Smith said.
"They want properly trained police officers with the powers to intervene, arrest and prevent crime. This is £2m of taxpayers' money being thrown at what can only be described as a gimmick."
View 2 Images Dublin Towns state that "security similar to that already in operation on the Luas" will be a good thing for those who live, work and visit Dublin city centre
This is exactly the same kind of pushback heard from Dublin councillors like Green Party Cllr Janet Horner and People Before Profit Cllr Conor Reddy, who both backed an unheard emergency motion demanding more information on the security scheme.
Cllr Horner is calling for “a more visible Garda presence” and said a “private security force” isn’t the support Dublin needs. She also highlighted the need to fund inner city projects for teenagers and at-risk youth in order to truly address root causes of anti-social behaviour.
“The Government could and should fund and back the many plans that the council have brought forward to address anti-social issues in the city instead of underfunding us to the point that a private security force is being considered. I am really concerned about the lack of political oversight around this,” she stated.
While the recently formed Local Community Safety Partnerships are investigating ways to increase safety on the streets, Cllr Horner stressed any proposal needs to be accompanied by “transparency and scrutiny”. “It seems to be a way of throwing money at enriching a private security firm while doing nothing to address the systemic issues in policing the city or support vulnerable and marginalised communities,” she said.
Cllr Reddy told Dublin Live that safety wardens have patrolled the city before, but he does not believe the answer to social problems will be found through private roles. “Investment should go into support services, outreach, youth work, and the Gardaí,” he said.
“The Gardaí have their job and they're the only ones really qualified to do it. There's oversight, arguably not enough, but there is oversight of them, and there's not really enough oversight of private security.”
While Dublin Town has pointed to private security being “successfully implemented by local authorities and police” in the United Kingdom, there have been incidents where these wardens have been accused of overstepping the boundaries of their role. As recently as October 22, the BBC reported accusations of assault and abuses of power by guards hired by Reform UK-led Essex County Council.
Colchester City Council heard a complaint of security handcuffing two female teenagers alleged to have been shoplifting. Labour Councillor Tim Young said the “power had gone to their heads” and Essex police stated that "learning requirements" had been "passed to the security staff employers".
The guards were hired as part of a three-month trial named Operation Vanguard in Braintree, Colchester and Chelmsford, towns said to be frequented by asylum seekers housed at a nearby military base. Essex County Council said they were there to "deter anti-social behaviour" in direct response to residents' concerns, and the scheme was backed by Reform leader Nigel Farage.
In 2023, the Guardian reported on a case involving a 15-year-old boy lying face down on the floor with two adult men kneeling on top of him. The men restraining him were not police officers, but security guards known as ‘rangers’. They were employed by a firm called Blayde Security, contracted by Chichester’s business improvement district (BID) to patrol the high street.
The aftermath of this incident saw the boy’s mother lead a campaign calling for a review of private security guards in Chichester to examine “what due diligence is carried out before rangers are hired, what training they receive and what their remit is”.
While security guards hold no extra powers above a regular citizen, the Guardian reported the ‘pseudo-police’ presentation of these uniformed wardens “can blur the boundaries” and offer the impression they have been endowed with a “level of authority that they do not merit”.
Reports also show that councils in England and Wales have hired private companies to patrol the streets and issue fines to the public for littering or fly-tipping. This saw accusations of contractors “adopting unscrupulous tactics to profit from people” according to a 2023 piece in the Guardian, which revealed 91,000 fines being issued between 2021-2022.
When news of private security in Dublin broke this week, many wondered if their role would include fining people for offenses such as littering, the maximum penalty for which was raised by Dublin City Council from €150 to €250 as of September this year. However, the council issued a statement reassuring the public that wardens will not have the power to “arrest, demand identification, require a person to leave a public street, to search persons, or issue fines/enforce local authority bye-laws.”
The details of what exactly private security patrols would entail in Dublin are still being hammered out, and the council said a full report on the topic will be included on the agenda of the upcoming December monthly meeting. References have been made to schemes from the UK, but DCC has already confirmed that will not extend to issuing fines.
Dublin Town has welcomed the proposal and said they are “happy” to “play a role in the implementation of a proposed pilot”. “Dublin Town has previously stated while businesses are consistently calling for additional Garda resources, initiatives that may improve safety must be trialled,” a spokesperson said.
“Dublin Town commissioned research by Red C into attitudes to Dublin City Centre last May. It found that while perceptions of the city centre in general are improving, safety remains a key challenge, particularly on the Northside. There was widespread reference by respondents to perceptions of safety, and says this must be addressed.
“Dublin Town will do all that it can to improve safety and perceptions of safety in the city centre, and believes this pilot will give people a sense of enhanced safety while supporting the important statutory role the Gardaí play in keeping our city safe.”
This content is funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme
Want to see more of the stories you love from Dublin Live? Making us your preferred source on Google means you’ll get more of our exclusives top stories and must-read content straight away. To add us as a preferred source, simply click here .
Reporting by Stephen Holland for DublinLive, funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme. Republished by News Room under the scheme’s reuse permission.
About News Room →