’Vanity project’ Christmas fair at Crescent gets green light but leaves sour taste for councillors
By Alan Jacques · Limerick Post · 11 November 2026

MAYOR John Moran’s Christmas Fayre at The Crescent on O’Connell Avenue has got the green light despite leaving a sour taste with councillors and being described as a "vanity project".
MAYOR John Moran’s Christmas Fayre at The Crescent on O’Connell Avenue has got the green light despite leaving a sour taste with councillors and being described as a “vanity project”.
At the opening of an epic six-and-a-half-hour meeting in Merchants Quay on Tuesday, the executive mayor paraphrased Irish patriot Robert Emmet when he spoke about “Limerick taking its place among the cities of the Earth”. However, by the end of his hard sell on closing The Crescent to traffic for six weeks during the festive season, he was hoping he wouldn’t end up the same way as the revolutionary leader.
“Unlike Robert Emmet, when the trial comes and we decide whether this is actually a good idea or not, nobody will be going out and executing the mayor over it,” he joked.
Mayor Moran talked about creating a Christmas market “of national importance”, but took the view that “we’ve gone way beyond” that.
He told Council members that local podcaster and author Blindboy Boatclub had high praise for his Christmas plans, but clearly not everyone in City Hall felt the same way about The Crescent as the location for a seasonal market.
Social Democrats councillor Elisa O’Donovan said she resented being asked to make a decision on The Crescent 44 days out from Christmas Eve “in which nobody wins”.
She took the view that elected representatives had been backed into a corner over plans for the Christmas Fayre.
“I resent being told that if we don’t approve this event license today, thousands of children and their families will miss out. I have asked people directly on my social media what they thought about the proposed locations, and what I saw is that the vast majority of those who responded wanted to see the Christmas Fayre in Arthur’s Quay Park. That was overwhelmingly the preference,” Cllr O’Donovan commented.
Independent councillor Ursula Gavan expressed her frustration at the last minute showdown to get Christmas over the line.
“Mother of God, Christmas is open in every town and city all over Europe, and we’re a laughing stock,” she said.
Cllr Shane Hickey-O’Mara felt the whole debacle left a “sour taste”.
“Limerick has lost out due to the divisiveness that has taken root,” he told the meeting.
Fine Gael councillor Peter Doyle expressed regret over how Christmas 2026 has been handled by Limerick Council.
“I think it’s very divisive. The Crescent fair could easily be moved to Pery Square without any inconvenience on traffic, and probably everybody would be happy with it,” he said.
Green Party councillor Seán Hartigan said he was looking forward to Christmas this year “more so than any other year”. He was also of the view that The Crescent was a “fantastic venue” for a festive fair.
“I don’t believe the traders will lose out on business. I truly believe there will be increased footfall, and I’m confident, from a business perspective, that it’ll be a bumper Christmas,” Cllr Hartigan said.
Labour Party councillor Joe Leddin wanted to know why The Crescent was “the only show in town” and whether other locations were considered.
“I am hugely disappointed effectively being boxed into a position,” he said.
Fianna Fáil councillor Catherine Slattery took the opportunity to address the “elephant in the room” at this the marathon special meeting.
“500 people put submissions in against the road closure in the Crescent, and we’ve heard no more about it. And when you query it, ‘oh, it’s an executive function’. I personally don’t care. 500 people are being ignored. Their opinion matters to me, but obviously it doesn’t matter to the Council,” she hit out.
Cllr Kieran O’Hanlon (FF) said it was a pity the season of good will had become so divisive for councillors in Limerick’s Metropolitan District.
“It’s absolutely deplorable. I do think that nearly every councillor here would want the fair not above in the Crescent. I think that’s the opinion nearly of everybody except the Green Party,” he suggested.
Labour Party councillor Pádraigh Reale started by addressing a number of traders who were present in the chamber to explain the “difficult position” they were being put in.
“We’ve come into this chamber with our hands tied behind our backs, effectively. What’s been presented to us here is Christmas or cancel,” he said.
Independent councilor Frankie Daly likened the Mayor’s speech at the beginning of the meeting to “a JFK or Martin Luther King”.
“It seemed like a fellow that was really prepped up by this Q4 marketing company, and it just doesn’t sit well with me. This whole debacle, the way it’s been done, I’m starting to think this is just a kind of a project of vanity, particularly towards the Crescent specifically,” he told the chamber.
Fine Gael councillor Daniel Butler was of the opinion that some of the “tactics” used during the process were “highly unusual”, like nothing he had experienced before.
He deemed it a “PR assault”, and called for an adjournment to discuss an alternative location for the Christmas fair.
After two and a half hours of private deliberation, conflicting legal advice, and further delays, the meeting was again opened to the public and press, where it was proposed that the fair be held in the vicinity of Arthur’s Quay Park.
Further legal advice was then called for in the chamber, before a vote could finally be considered after much back and forth.
However, by meeting’s end, the Mayor’s Christmas Fayre at the Crescent saw a green light, but only just by the skin of its teeth.
A proposal to have it moved to Arthur’s Quay was defeated by 9 votes to 8.
Cllrs Sarah Beasley (Aontú), Sharon Benson (SF), Maria Donoghue (IND), Ursula Gava (IND), Seán Hartigan (GP), Fergus Kilcoyne (FF), Joe Leddin (LAB), Pádraigh Reale (LAB), and Azad Talukder (FF) all voted against moving the fair to the vicinity of Arthur’s Quay Park.
Councillors Daniel Butler (FG), Frankie Daly (IND), Sarah Kiely (FG), Dan McSweeney (FG), Kieran O’Hanlon (FF), Joe Pond (FF), Olivia O’Sullivan (FG), and Catherine Slattery (FF) were in favour of the move.
Abstentions came from councillors Elisa O’Donovan (SD), Shane Hickey-O’Mara (SD), and Peter Doyle (FG). Cllr Elena Secas (IND) was absent.
Reporting by Alan Jacques for Limerick Post, funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme. Republished by News Room under the scheme’s reuse permission.
About News Room →