Local news from all 26 countiesAbout us

Drink driving conviction overturned on appeal - Courts News Ireland

By Fionnuala Walsh · Courts News Ireland · 6 November 2026

A woman who was accused of drink driving and failing to sign a breath analysis statement has had her conviction overturned on appeal. Judge Elizabeth Maguire told the District Court Appeals Court she was not satisfied that Grainne Mary Kenny (59) was kept under observation for 20 minutes before receiving a test for alcohol levels. She decided to allow her

A woman who was accused of drink driving and failing to sign a breath analysis statement has had her conviction overturned on appeal.

Judge Elizabeth Maguire told the District Court Appeals Court she was not satisfied that Grainne Mary Kenny (59) was kept under observation for 20 minutes before receiving a test for alcohol levels. She decided to allow her appeal against conviction on these grounds.

Ms Kenny, with an address on Martello Road, Balbriggan, Dublin, was convicted in the District Court of driving a mechanically propelled vehicle while under influence of intoxicant or if exceeding alcohol limits, contrary to section 4(4)(a) and 4(5) of the Road Traffic Act 2010.

She was also convicted of failure or refusal to sign an analysis statement, contrary to section 13(3)(4) of the same act.

Ms Kenny was originally given a fine of €400 and a three-year disqualification for the first charge and a €100 fine for the second. She later lodged an appeal against the conviction.

Garda Stephen Murphy told the court that he was on patrol on Hamlet Lane, Balbriggan on June 10, 2022 and observed a car driving at a very slow speed.

He said that the car seemed to be staggering forward with sudden breaking movements. He said that the car attempted to turn right but stopped suddenly and obstructed the road.

Garda Murphy said that he spoke to the driver and made efforts to ascertain why she was driving in that manner. He said that she attempted to make a response but that her speech was extremely slurred and that she was non-coherent.

He said he heard her say that there was a flat tyre on the vehicle, which he observed.

Garda Murphy said that there was a very strong smell of alcohol coming from the driver and her vehicle. He said that she refused to provide her details to him.

He said that a subsequent breath specimen at the garda station produced a result of 67mg alcohol per 100ml of breath, where the limit is 22mg. He said he observed that the appellant failed to sign one of the statements provided by the apparatus.

The garda said he was satisfied that the car’s tyre was flat but that it would not have caused the manner of erratic driving. He said that he was not able to decipher anything other than the driver’s reference to the tyre.

He said that “essentially I thought she was drunk, her speech was slurred”.

Defence counsel, Martin Joseph Dully BL, said his instructions are that Ms Kenny had experienced an extremely difficult personal matter on the night this occurred.

Garda Murphy said that he had a recollection of another garda explaining her rights in the station.

Another garda, who operated the ‘Evidenzer’ breath testing machine, told the court that he observed Ms Kenny complete a nil by mouth period of twenty minutes.

He said that as she was taken to get the breath test taken, she demanded to use the bathroom and said that if she didn’t do so she would urinate on herself.

The witness said that another garda entered the bathroom with Ms Kenny, that the door was slightly ajar and that he could see the sink.

The garda said that Ms Kenny also refused on numerous occasions to sign one of the certificates produced by the breath test machine.

He said it was clear that Ms Kenny was intoxicated, that she was slurring her words and “arguing with everything”.

Mr Dully said that there was a missing witness in the case – the garda who completed the custody record. He said that if a person refuses to sign the custody record, the refusal by the person must be noted on the record.

He said that there was a “manifest defect” in the custody record and that the prosecution had chosen to come to court without the garda who completed it.

Mr Dully said that this missing garda also facilitated Ms Kenny’s request to go to the bathroom. He said that by the prosecution not calling this witness, it breaks the continuation of the nil by mouth observation. He said that there was an admission by the garda of having of no line of sight in the bathroom.

Prosecution counsel said that the third garda was not required to give evidence. She said that Garda Murphy was present for the entire time that Ms Kenny was given her notice of rights.

She said that the garda was also there to observe the twenty minutes of nil by mouth. She said that he had a sight of the sink, which he said was the only way the appellant could have taken anything.

Judge Maguire said that she accepted the evidence of the garda that Ms Kenny received the relevant information and that she did not find with the defence on the custody regulations point.

However, she accepted the defence submission that Ms Kenny was not under observation for twenty minutes. She accepted that the garda was outside looking at the sink but said that he was not watching Ms Kenny.

The judge said she was not satisfied that the period was complied with. She accepted that there were logistical difficulties with the toilet, but said that there were other ways around it and that perhaps the period of observation should have restarted.

Judge Maguire said she was not satisfied that Ms Kenny was kept under observation for 20 minutes and that she would allow the appeal.

View original story

Reporting by Fionnuala Walsh for Courts News Ireland, funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme. Republished by News Room under the scheme’s reuse permission.

About News Room →