Local news from all 26 countiesAbout us

Donegal councillor calls time on politicians giving court references - Donegal Daily

By Rachel McLaughlin · Donegal Daily · 11 November 2026

Donegal county councillor Jimmy Kavanagh has secured support for a motion calling on Fine Gael to restrict its elected representatives from providing character...

Donegal county councillor Jimmy Kavanagh has secured support for a motion calling on Fine Gael to restrict its elected representatives from providing character references in criminal court cases.

The Letterkenny councillor's motion, submitted on behalf of the Donegal Constituency Executive, was unanimously agreed at the party's Ard Fheis in Cork over the weekend.

The proposal argues that character references from politicians can 'create a perception that political influence may affect judicial proceedings'.

Cllr Kavanagh said: "Public representatives are often asked to provide references for people coming before the courts, this creates several difficulties.

"The public representative is usually approached by someone who is close to him/her on behalf of the individual and put in a difficult situation, where refusal might offend."

He also warned that “The full facts of the case may not be disclosed to the public representative prior to the reference being provided.”

Cllr Kavanagh said the principle of equality before the law must be protected.

“Everyone should be treated equally before the courts irrespective of their status, political connections or place in society,” he said.

Suits you! Rosses AC runner completes Clontarf Half Marathon in style

In Pictures: #BuyDonegal launches at Ballybofey Christmas Markets

“Allowing public representatives to provide character references could create the impression that people with political connections enjoy an advantage not available to other defendants.”

He also raised concerns about the effect on victims, stating: “The victim of a crime may feel their credibility is being challenged or undermined if a prominent public representative is being supportive of the accused.”

Cllr Kavanagh argued that a clear prohibition would also help politicians deal with requests from people they know.

“A prohibition would remove the possibility of any actual or perceived conflict of interest and would give the public representative a legitimate reason to refuse without having to feel embarrassed if the person requesting the reference, is a close acquaintance.”

Fine Gael is expected to fine tune and adopt a policy prohibiting such references and to encourage similar standards across public life.

Cllr Kavanagh's motion also emphasised that public confidence in the justice system depends on the principle that all citizens are equal before the law, regardless of their status or political connections.

View original story

Reporting by Rachel McLaughlin for Donegal Daily, funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme. Republished by News Room under the scheme’s reuse permission.

About News Room →