Roads offender has fine for having no insurance removed on appeal - Courts News Ireland
By Fionnuala Walsh · Courts News Ireland · 5 November 2026

A roads offender has had her fine for driving with no insurance removed on appeal after a judge told her “it will only get worse” if she offends again. The District Court Appeals Court heard that Kathleen McDonagh (37) was under “immense financial pressure”, with her solicitor telling the court that this was an exceptional case. McDonagh, with an address in
A roads offender has had her fine for driving with no insurance removed on appeal after a judge told her “it will only get worse” if she offends again.
The District Court Appeals Court heard that Kathleen McDonagh (37) was under “immense financial pressure”, with her solicitor telling the court that this was an exceptional case.
McDonagh, with an address in Kylemore Grove, Ballyfermot, Dublin 10, was convicted in the District Court of driving without insurance, failing to produce a licence or insurance, and another failure to produce a licence within 10 days.
She was given a six-year disqualification, a three-month suspended sentence and a fine of €800. She later lodged an appeal against the severity of her sentence.
Sergeant Shay Leonard told the court that on April 13, 2025, gardai on mobile patrol stopped a Volvo car on the Kylemore Road, Ballyfermot.
He said that McDonagh did not have documents on the roadside and failed to produce them to a garda station.
Sergeant Leonard said that McDonagh was previously disqualified for four years for another incident and that she has a total of ten previous road traffic convictions.
Defence solicitor for McDonagh, Lorraine Stevens, said that she was appealing the case on the basis of the severity of the fine imposed.
She said that her client was fully reliant on social welfare and has children with special needs.
Ms Stevens said that McDonagh was under “immense financial pressure” and asked the judge to dispense with the fine.
She said that she had been punished and that this is an exceptional case in terms of finances.
Judge Elizabeth Maguire said that McDonagh should know the “peril she is in” and that there was to be no more driving without insurance.
She said that “it will only get worse” and that McDonagh has gotten a lot of leeway so far.
The judge decided to affirm the District Court orders in relation to the disqualification but dispensed with the fine.
Reporting by Fionnuala Walsh for Courts News Ireland, funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme. Republished by News Room under the scheme’s reuse permission.
About News Room →